Changing knowledge of citizens and practitioners in times of crisis: The aftermath of Fukushima

This blog is the second of a series of blogs linked to the Evidence & Policy special issue (Volume 16, Issue 2) on Opening up evidence-based policy: exploring citizen and service user expertise. Guest Edited by Ellen Stewart, Jennifer Smith-Merry, and Marc Geddes.

Tazuko Arai

Dear friends,

            How are you doing? You told me how you could not stop binging on COVID-19 news. So, I am sending you something different: “Risk, uncertainty and medical practice: changes in the medical professions following disaster” by Sudeepa Abeysinghe et al. I can see you wince, complaining that a paper written about a nuclear disaster that happened 9 years earlier has nothing to do with what we are undergoing now (note: this piece was written in March-April 2020). Well, I would argue that the paper is quite relevant today because it gives us perspective on how the medical professionals stretched their roles/responsibilities in times of crisis. You told me of your deep respect for these professionals, and I believe this paper will increase your understanding of their challenges and even deepen your appreciation.

Continue reading

Evidence, Medicine and Art – Lived Experience Completing the Picture

This blog is the first of a series of blogs linked to the Evidence & Policy special issue (Volume 16, Issue 2) on Opening up evidence-based policy: exploring citizen and service user expertise. Guest Edited by Ellen Stewart, Jennifer Smith-Merry, and Marc Geddes.

Laila Hallam

Recently I came upon this photo in a post in Twitter[1].  I have seen it before.  It’s a powerful image by Sir Luke Fields.  The child and doctor at the centre, in the glow of the lamp.   The child ill and exhausted.  The doctor earnestly observing.  Watching.  Sitting.  Waiting.  Thinking.  Previously, and again this time, I absorb this painting as a statement on the medical profession.  A reminder of the solemness of their work.  The gravity of life and death.  The role of the family in the background, secondary and in the dark.

But then I was challenged to really look at the image.  The Dad wasn’t simply in the background, he was standing in the shadows, he was stoic, he was purposefully and intently studying the doctor for signals.  Only after considerable prodding, did I notice Dad’s hand comforting his distraught wife.  The Mum collapsed in prayer, or distress, or both.  Dad’s hand gently on her shoulder, reassuring her, or maybe channelling his energy into her prayer.  Her faith.  Their hope.

Continue reading

Evidence & Policy insights during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Kat Smith and Paul Cairney

The COVID-19 pandemic is shining a light on the roles that evidence and expertise can play in policy and practice. Understanding the nature of these debates, and developing tools to help decision-makers navigate them, is the focus of the Evidence & Policy community. In this post, we consider how our reflections on the field’s key insights help us understand the role evidence is playing in the UK’s response to the current pandemic:

Continue reading

Lessons for public health decision making in urgent and uncertain times

The ECDC Public Health Emergency Team

Accounts of medical professionals performing triage due to the over-burden of healthcare systems during the COVID-19 pandemic are hard to hear. They are a microcosm of dynamics that are occurring globally, where public health authorities and governments are attempting to simultaneously understand and respond to a swiftly moving global pandemic. In this article, the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control Public Health Emergency team* offer lessons from recent history for decision making during this difficult time.

Continue reading